The Valmiki community's protest against empty political gestures — and an oppressive occupation

By Manisha Mashaal, Mar 04, 2019 22:22:51 IST

Translated from Hindi by Bishaldeb Halder

Every second, the Valmiki community's dignity and rights are murdered.

Our history has been written with tears of blood. For how long will our truth be obscured? On your pages lies our truth that nobody else has bothered to know. I want to place this important truth before society, in the light of recent events.

I am aware that when I state this, I will immediately be met with replies like ‘yes, this is a very grave issue, it must be highlighted', or 'it is time to shatter the silence around it’. But the fact remains that there is no one who wishes to work for the emancipation of this community. An example of this was seen at an exhibition on 24 February, at the Kumbh Mela.

Two ladies from the Valmiki community, Jyoti and Chhavi Devi, and three gentlemen, Pyarelal, Naresh Chandra and Horilal, had their feet washed — a 'great' deed, apparently. It has only instilled a sense of inferiority in us.

This act only serves to make us more untouchable.

There is a very old custom in this society of immediately taking a bath upon being touched by an “untouchable”, in order to purify oneself. How cruelly ironic that the same custom should be practiced on the people from our community in order to “respect” them!

We belong to a community that is considered untouchable even among the Dalits. It is such beliefs and views that need to be cleansed, not our feet.

It is this same set of beliefs that has led to this grand gesture. Since these people are from untouchable communities, care must be taken to see that their feet are not filthy, lest the entire arrangement should be polluted. That is why the gesture was made.

Why were they not honoured inside the temple where the worship occurs? Because, even today, members of our community are not allowed inside temples. After washing our dirty feet, you are honouring us. Is this honour or insult? What answer do we give to our raging minds?

Touching our feet is a bit excessive. We don’t even need you to make our community a vote bank; we sacrifice millions of votes for you anyway. If you are ready to become a great leader, pick up your pen and write that no one from the sanitation worker communities will engage in sanitation work and scavenging henceforth, in the country.

Did the Prime Minister not feel inclined to listen to the ‘Mann ki Baat’ of these workers? As for them, why did they not speak about their problems: their children’s education, their own health, their financial condition and the grossly unhygienic conditions of their work?

Why is such honour bestowed upon us around the time of the elections and not at all the other times when our people clean toilets and pick up others’ leftover food and utensils at railway stations with their own hands?

There is no proper protective clothing provided at all. Our mothers and sisters are forced to listen to remarks like ‘Can’t you see I’m walking here; my clothes will be soiled now’ while at work. What do you think they feel at being told off by young children half their age? Why is this so?

This is because the Valmiki community, on account of the work they are engaged in, are considered dirty and polluting. This issue has been relegated to the sidelines. The Swachh Bharat Abhiyan was inaugurated on 2 October 2014 with a budget of Rs 1.95 lakh crore, that was meant to be spent on building 1.2 lakh toilets in order to end the practice of open defecation. How many sanitation workers were honoured then? On the contrary, there was greater recruitment of such workers for cleaning these toilets.

Can there not be greater deeds than washing feet? And why now? So much money has been spent in the name of the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan. But has there been any provision made for educating the children of these families? Has there been any explanation or basis given for this historically unhygienic custom?

There have been so many universities built in the name of society. Have there been any martyr memorials built for those who sacrificed their lives in order to make the country clean?

Have their children been provided with jobs, or have any leaders offered consolation to such families?

In the heated cauldron of Indian politics, the Kumbh Mela is organised, where people take a dip in the Ganga, the Gita is read — and members of the Valmiki community only are given the job of cleaning. Of all these people, only three men and two women were chosen to have their feet washed by the Prime Minister in bronze vessels. It escapes comprehension as to why this was done right before the 2019 General Elections.

To this day, hundreds of thousands of people have died in the sewers due to inhaling toxic gases and ingesting the filth and nightsoil. Nobody has even bothered about their families. There are countless women who fall prey to several diseases while doing sanitation work, as a result of which their children are forced to take up the profession in their stead. There are no fixed timings for sanitation workers; they usually start their work before daybreak and have to continue working till late at night, in order to make ends meet.

If I speak in the context of Haryana, where I hail from, the Valmiki community has very little access to education. In villages, girls from the Valmiki community have to carry the filth and garbage of the rest of society, when they should actually be studying. Thus, the hope and promise of a bright future is snuffed out by this dirty custom.

For women of our community, this act of cleaning garbage begins in the dark of the night. Before daybreak, the mud, refuse and nightsoil of the entire village are already on the heads of the women and men of our community. Even all the refuse and nightsoil has a higher status than that of the members of our community. For I have always seen them weighed down by it. Everyday we are humiliated with the slur ‘choorha’, meaning an insect crawling in muck. What sort of dignity do we have?

Why does the act of carrying refuse begin at 4 am? So that nobody sees us in this act.

I have mostly seen the members of my community cursing governments for leaving them in such a condition. But when there was talk of an era of development, there were high hopes within the community. They believed they would progress too, and that their children would have brighter futures. Why has this ended up as a mere dream for my community?

Education is the only means by which the Valmiki community can bring about its intellectual development, by which it can hope for more gainful employment, and to break free of the shackles of such a profession. It is tragic that the situation of the sanitation workers with regard to education remains so worrying. A research study conducted by the Indian Social Institute across the states of Uttar Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, Haryana, Rajasthan, Bihar, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, and southern states like Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Telangana, Andhra Pradesh concluded that a mere 0.6 percent of youth from sanitation worker communities manages to reach higher education. The study makes it clear that after the intermediate level, these students are forced to drop out.

The main reason for this is the lack of access to schools. Even when there is access, there are other reasons for the overwhelming dropout rates, such as the discrimination practised by teachers, weak financial condition and the negative self-esteem that these students develop as a result of constantly working with their parents in this profession. Even today, there is open and public discrimination practised by teachers towards children coming from sanitation worker families. Nothing has changed despite such discrimination being punishable by law. To this day, these children are forced to do sanitation work in schools.

For children from such families, the only source of education is the state government-run school. But the aforementioned study has also revealed that these schools are bereft of even the minimum facilities mandated by the Right to Education Act. Even after studying in these schools, these students cannot prepare themselves for good employment opportunities and competitive examinations, and have, perforce, to stick to their caste-ordained occupation.

Another reason for this is that our community has been denied any opportunity to acquire technical and professional skills such as mechanical work, electrical work etc. In such a scenario, having relinquished their caste-based unskilled work, they can find no other opportunities. The community continues to be trapped in this profession, generation after generation.

In the last few years, through the efforts of the Safai Karmachari Andolan and several other human rights organisations, new laws were passed in Parliament that made manual scavenging a crime. In spite of this, neither have the deaths in septic tanks stopped nor has the number of people recruited in other forms of sanitation work reduced. What is it that keeps people from these families from leaving their caste-ordained professions?

On 25 February, 2019, a day after Prime Minister Narendra Modi honoured the five sanitation workers, Darshan Ratna Raavan, chief of the Aadi Dharm Samaaj (AADHAS), had gathered along with thousands of members of the Valmiki community at Jantar Mantar, New Delhi, in order to protest the deaths of sanitation workers and to fight for the rights of the community. There were thousands of women demanding justice for their family members, who had lost their lives in the sewers.

Photograph courtesy of Darshan Ratna Raavan

They were demanding that sanitation workers be given reservations. Till date, they have not been given any accommodation. Neither have their children been given any government jobs. They are far away from receiving any monetary compensation or damages. Such a situation only exists because there has been no implementation of our constitutionally guaranteed rights. If their demands could be met, it would lead to a very welcome social change.

As a female leader from the Valmiki community, I can clearly see that there has been a huge contribution by the sanitation worker communities in bringing you to power. Is it not the responsibility of the present administration that new schemes are devised for the development of our community, so that we too may join the mainstream? Or will we always be seen as a vote-bank? This attitude needs to change; we cannot see any more people lose their lives by drowning in filth. Otherwise, there is going to be large-scale opposition from our community, which will not be favourable to the current administration.

The practice of manual scavenging was banned by law in 1993, and yet it persists tenaciously. It was Bezwada Wilson’s initiative to fight for the rights and dignity of sanitation workers that spread the movement to every corner of the country. The movement highlighted the failure of implementation of this law in everyday life. It brought the attention of the government to this issue. In this context, here are a few questions that I would like to raise:

—Since the practice of manual scavenging and manual cleaning of sewers is banned by law, what has been done to ensure the implementation of this law? Because both these practices continue to exist in full force. Is it not the responsibility of the administration to check this?

—Does the administration not feel the need to look at the data on the number of people from the community who have lost their lives while working in sewers?

—Will the responsibility for the continuation of this dirty custom, that is being done by the administration, be taken up by the present government? Or will they introduce mechanical cleaning of sewers? Are there any machines for this purpose in your records? If there aren’t, what do you say is the basis of these “suicides” that occur in the gutters and manholes? Because there is a law against this in our Constitution.

—Are these workers committing suicide in the sewers?

—Does the self-respect and education of the Valmiki community in this country have no meaning for you?

—If those in charge of running the country are themselves encouraging these practices, who do we go to in order to press for the implementation of these laws?

The practice of keeping sanitation workers deliberately on contract and making them work in the sewers must be stopped. It is clearly evident that the state and administration have failed in implementing and upholding the rule of law. Nothing else can explain the continuation of these practices even after so many years of them being banned by law.

We would be happy if the Prime Minister would grant members of our community special reservations, through which we can avail of special positions in education and employment.

I would like to propose the following provisions and safeguards regarding employment opportunities and practices of the Valmiki community:

—Appointing some members of this community as judges

—Those sanitation workers who have lost their lives while working be granted the status of sanitation soldiers (Safai Sainik)

—There should be a provision by which all education of children belonging to sanitation worker families, from primary to higher education, be completely free

—The wages of those from our community who are engaged in this profession must be four times those of Grade A government officers. Since the pursuit of this profession involves humiliation at every moment, it is an exceedingly difficult job, one that they do by causing harm to their own self-respect

—Sewers must be cleaned using machines. The practice of sacrificing people from our community like animals must be stopped.

—It is very important to provide those engaged in scavenging with reservations based on economic, social, educational and political backwardness. Our community has been cleaning the filth of society for thousands of years in the face of such contempt and humiliation, to the extent that we have internalised this within our own community.

—We have been excluded from every kind of institution. We want a life of dignity in this country. Provide us with alternative opportunities, and make us part of the mainstream.

Till date, the mothers in my community have not been able to impart good education to their children, because the garbage of your society was being cleaned by them — for which they have never ever received fair and necessary wages. Society, as a whole, is responsible for this. But this debt lies in your hands; you can repay it if you want to. We are asking for our rights from the government of our country at the Kumbh Mela this year. This is not charity; these are our rights. Just give us our rights! Understand the value of our community or at least try to.

There cannot be a bigger deed during this Kumbh Mela than the present administration accepting our demands.

All images from Facebook unless specified otherwise

Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the latest analysis, commentary and news updates, sign up for our WhatsApp services. Just go toFirstpost.com/Whatsapp and hit the Subscribe button.

India denied visas to Pakistani pilgrims who want to visit Ajmer Sharif Dargah for Urs celebration, claims minister

By Asian News International, Mar 05, 2019 09:37:23 IST

Every year, around 500 Pakistani pilgrims attend the Urs celebration at Ajmer Sharif Dargah, considered to be one of the holiest Muslim shrines in India
The Pakistani minister further claimed that this is the second consecutive time when India has refused visas to Pakistani pilgrims
In March last year, India had reportedly refused to issue visas to 503 Pakistani pilgrims visiting the Urs celebration, he said

Islamabad: Minister of Religious Affairs and Interfaith Harmony Sahibzada Noor Al Haq Qadri on Monday said India has denied issuing visas to the Pakistani pilgrims who wanted to attend the Urs celebration of Sufi saint Khawaja Moinuddin Chishti.

The celebration is slated to be held in Ajmer Sharif Dargah in India this month.

The dargah of Sufi saint Khawaja Moinuddin Chisti. Wikimedia Commons

Dawn quoted the minister as saying that around 500 Pakistani pilgrims were supposed to leave for India on 7 March.

The remarks by the Minister come amid escalating tension between India and Pakistan following the Pulwama terror attack on 14 February that killed 40 Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) personnel and a series of air strikes by both the neighbouring countries since the past few days.

"India's extremist face has come forward," Qadri said in a statement adding that "India is held hostage by religious extremists."

The Pakistani minister further claimed that this is the second consecutive time when India has refused visas to Pakistani pilgrims.

In March last year, India had reportedly refused to issue visas to 503 Pakistani pilgrims visiting the Urs celebration. However, only 190 of 400 visa requests had been approved by the Indian Embassy during the Urs of Hazrat Nizamuddin Aulia in New Delhi, he added.

Qadri further noted that the Indian embassy in Islamabad had informed the ministry regarding the cancellation of visas of the pilgrims.

The embassy has yet to return the passports of the visa applicants.

Every year, around 500 Pakistani pilgrims attend the Urs celebration at the Ajmer Sharif Dargah, considered to be one of the holiest Muslim shrines in India.

Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the latest analysis, commentary and news updates, sign up for our WhatsApp services. Just go toFirstpost.com/Whatsapp and hit the Subscribe button.

SHOW FULL STORY

Narendra Modi's insensitive remark on dyslexia reaffirms India's narrow understanding of mental health concerns

By Divya Srivastava, Mar 05, 2019 10:26:13 IST

PM Modi has been criticised for seemingly taking a jibe at the Gandhis by making a reference to dyslexia and children who have been labelled as dyslexic.
Modi’s statement is an apt picture of all that’s wrong with our education system and our country in general.
Policy-makers themselves need to receive proper education, knowledge and training before rolling things out to the masses.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has been criticised for seemingly taking a jibe at the Gandhis — Rahul and Sonia — by making a reference to dyslexia and children who have been labelled as dyslexic. Modi’s passing remark was insensitive, but it’s made worse by the occasion on which he made it: a competition called the “Smart India Hackathon”.

The stigma associated with mental health and associated diagnostic labels is still strong in India. Before one addresses Modi’s comments, it is important to note that a few things were wrong with the student’s presentation.

The BTech student from Uttarakhand said her project will help “dyslexic children”. One of the major hurdles in fighting the stigma surrounding mental health is the manner in which individuals are reduced to nothing but labels. In everyday conversations, we do not make passing remarks about that “diabetic friend” or the “asthmatic boss”. We just acknowledge that there are individuals diagnosed with diabetes, asthma, or some other chronic, physical condition. So, why are children with the label of “dyslexia” not considered to be anything else but that?

File image of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Reuters/Kim Hong-Ji

Diagnostic labels help individuals access public services and gain access to communities of individuals with the same label. However, ongoing research indicates that getting a diagnostic label does not guarantee getting the right treatment, and it often does more harm than good for it is often associated with worry and stigma (Corrigan, 2004). Many-a-times, people fail to see beyond labels. Moreover, two people with the same label may not require the same treatment as their cluster of symptoms may differ.

Unfortunately, a lot of mental health professionals and educators overlook the damages that a disempowering label can cause, and choose to use it liberally — without realising that under the garb of providing an explanation for certain symptoms, they are actually making that individual more vulnerable to negative biases and stigma.

Coming back to the student’s presentation, in an unintended irony, she mentioned the film Taare Zameen Par — a movie that raised awareness among audiences and drove home the message that children should not be defined by their disabilities, and that any disability should be viewed as being integral to a child’s identity. However, by laughing at Modi’s remark along with the audience, the student failed to practice what she was preaching, and reduced a child to a mere label.

How can one build a product to help a group when one does not display a basic level of empathy for that group in the first place? We are aware of the ridicule students with special needs are often subjected to by their peers, teachers, parents and society at large. Modi deserves no accolades for the statement he made, but the audience’s reaction was equally loathsome.

Another important point to note is that dyslexia is no longer a preferred term of use. According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (or the DSM-V) that was published in 2013, dyslexia is now sub-categorised as a “specific learning disorder”. Specific learning disorder is now an umbrella term for mathematics, reading, and writing expression disorders – previously, the DSM-IV classified these as separate diagnoses. Specific learning disorder with impairment in reading is the alternate term for dyslexia, and it includes possible deficits in word reading accuracy, reading rate or fluency, and reading comprehension. It is unfortunate that Smart India Hackathon, a nationwide platform of innovation for young minds, does not encourage its participants to stay up-to-date with the right vocabulary.

An individual no longer needs to be subject to IQ tests or neuropsychological assessments of cognitive processing skills to receive a diagnosis of specific learning disorder, which means that there is no link between this processing disorder and intelligence. Most parents struggle to understand that. They make the mistake of attributing the child’s inability to perform tasks of reading or writing to traits like “laziness” or “stupidity”, and they end up feeling frustrated when their child is not able to perform as well as his or her peers. Educators and school psychologists find it really difficult to work through these issues because, by and large, we are living in a world where everyone has a high drive for achievement and no one wants to be left behind in the competition to reach the top.

Modi’s statement — that if the student’s presentation helped a 40/50-year-old man, then that would make the mother of such a child happy — is an apt picture of all that’s wrong with our education system and our country in general. Things that are wrong with the Indian education system could be a debate for another day, but drawing simply from that one statement of Modi’s, it is evident that appreciation is always for achievement and not for effort.

Children, with or without special needs, must obtain a certain rank or achieve certain marks in order to make their parents proud. Rather than being happy with the amount of time and effort the child is putting into any activity, the focus is on how well the child has performed. It is, therefore, no surprise that 37 percent of students across colleges in India are diagnosed with depression or other mental illnesses (Deb et.al., 2016). Managing expectations is a struggle that only intensifies as individuals move to higher levels of education.

This is not the first time our government has displayed its narrow understanding of mental health. In June 2018, the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare faced a lot of flak for putting up a poster on depression that not only attempted to over-simplify the condition, but also conveyed insensitive, misleading information. Modi’s recent statements reaffirm that adoption of new innovations or implementation of new policies cannot bring about any significant change unless we invest in changing the mind-sets of the people in society. For that to happen, policy-makers themselves need to receive proper education, knowledge and training before rolling things out to the masses.

The author is a Mumbai-based counsellor and psychotherapist.

***

References:

Corrigan, Patrick. “How stigma interferes with mental health care.” https://psycnet.apa.org/buy/2004-19091-003 American Psychologist, Vol 59 (7), October 2004, pp. 614-625.

Deb. et. al. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1876201815301179

Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the latest analysis, commentary and news updates, sign up for our WhatsApp services. Just go toFirstpost.com/Whatsapp and hit the Subscribe button.

SHOW FULL STORY

Narendra Modi's gaffe in Gujarat, says 'Karachi’ instead of ‘Kochi’, claims ‘mind is occupied’ with Pakistan

By Press Trust Of India, Mar 05, 2019 10:29:37 IST

Narendra Modi on Monday got 'Kochi' in Kerala and 'Karachi' in Pakistan mixed up in a slip of the tongue
He quickly covered it up by saying that his mind these days is preoccupied with Pakistan
Modi was addressing a gathering after inaugurating a 750-bed annexe building of Guru Govind Singh Hospital

Jamnagar: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Monday got 'Kochi' in Kerala and 'Karachi' in Pakistan mixed up in a slip of the tongue but quickly covered it up by saying that his mind these days is preoccupied with the neighbouring country.

File photo of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. ANI

Extolling the virtues of the Ayushman Bharat health scheme, Modi said it allowed a resident of Jamnagar to avail treatment anywhere in the country, be it 'Kolkata' or 'Karachi'. Almost in the same breath, the prime minister set things right by telling the gathering he meant 'Kochi' and not 'Karachi'.

"Under the Ayushman Bharat scheme, if a resident of Jamangar has gone to Bhopal and falls sick, he need not come back to Jamnagar for treatment. If he shows his (Ayushman Bharat) beneficiary card, he will get free treatment even in Kolkata and even in Karachi," Modi told the gathering.

He, however, added, "Not Karachi but Kochi. Nowadays my mind is preoccupied with the thoughts of the neighbouring country." "But that (air strike in Pakistan) was also necessary. Should that be done or not?" he posed to the crowd which replied its assent with a round of applause.

Modi was addressing a gathering after inaugurating a 750-bed annexe building of Guru Govind Singh Hospital.

Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the latest analysis, commentary and news updates, sign up for our WhatsApp services. Just go toFirstpost.com/Whatsapp and hit the Subscribe button.

SHOW FULL STORY

Navy chief Admiral Sunil Lanba warns of 'serious threat of state-sponsored terrorism seeking to destablise country'

By FP Staff, Mar 05, 2019 10:58:14 IST

'We have reports of terrorists being trained to carry out operations in various modus operandi including through the medium of the sea,' Lanba said
The navy chief said that India faces a far more serious version of this state-sponsored terrorism
Lanba also said that the Indo-pacific region has witnessed multiple forms of terrorism in recent years

Naval Chief Admiral Sunil Lanba on Tuesday highlighted the threats being faced by India in the Indo-Pacific region as well called out the 'state' seeking to destabilise India by aiding the perpetuation of extremists-led violence in the country.

Naval Chief Sunil Lanba briefed the media on Tuesday. ANI

"We have reports of terrorists being trained to carry out operations in various modus operandi including through the medium of the sea," Lanba said in a media briefing.

He, however, said that India faces a far more serious version of this state-sponsored terrorism. "We have all witnessed the horrific scale of extremists attack on the Indian state of Jammu and Kashmir, just three weeks ago," he said.

Lanba said that the Indo-pacific region has witnessed multiple forms of terrorism in recent years and few countries in this part of the world have been spared by this cause. "Global nature which terrorism has acquired in recent times has further enhanced the scope of this threat," the chief of naval staff said.

India had carried out air-strikes on 26 February in Pakistan's Balakot on to target a Jaish-e-Mohammed (JeM) training camp at Jaba top after a JeM suicide bomber-led attack killed 40 CRPF jawans in Pulwama district of Jammu and Kashmir on 14 February. Thereafter, an aerial dogfight on the LoC had ensued between the two nations on 27 February in which one MiG-21 and a Pakistani F-16 fighter jet were shot down.

Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the latest analysis, commentary and news updates, sign up for our WhatsApp services. Just go toFirstpost.com/Whatsapp and hit the Subscribe button.

SHOW FULL STORY

Click

FOOTSTEPS

Tuesday, 5 March 2019